On Monday the justices took the unusual step of applying the 2012 ruling retroactively, meaning that all those juvenile murderers sentenced to such automatic life terms in the past will have a chance for release.
Advertisement
Don’t expect the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling Monday that grants hundreds of prisoners convicted of murder as juveniles the chance of parole to have a big impact in Iowa.
Levick, who served as co-counsel on the case, said this ruling will allow individuals who may have spent many decades in prison to have their cases reviewed, then possibly be granted parole and returned into society.
The United States Supreme Court has declared invalid a portion of every sentence nationwide that imposed a mandatory punishment of life in prison without the possibility of parole for those who committed their crimes as juveniles.
In its 2012 decision, the Supreme Court said that judges can not automatically sentence juvenile offenders to life without parole.
“The opportunity for release will be afforded to those who demonstrate the truth of Miller’s central intuition-that children who commit even heinous crimes are capable of change”, Kennedy wrote.
Although the court in 2012 had not altogether barred mandatory life without parole sentences, it was reserved for crimes reflecting “irreparable corruption”, Kennedy said. The Louisiana Supreme Court disagreed, and his challenge made it to the nation’s highest judicial body.
Montgomery, convicted of the fatal shooting of a deputy in East Baton Rouge Parish, has been at the Louisiana State Penitentiary in Angola since 1963. “This conscription into federal service of state postconviction courts is nothing short of astonishing”, Scalia wrote.
One case that will not be affected is that of Christian Kenyon, a former Scranton resident who was sentenced to life without parole for his role in a gang-related killing in 2009, when he was 17.
Justice Scalia wrote a scathing dissent.
Montgomery is now 69, and for his entire adult life has known nothing but the prison system.
Sen. Bob Dixon says Missouri has no alternative sentence that’s constitutional for minors convicted of first-degree murder, other than life in prison without parole.
In a separate dissent, Thomas said the majority’s decision “repudiates established principles of finality” and “finds no support in the Constitution’s text”.
Those 16 or 17 years old at the time of the crime would face at least 50 years in prison or life without parole under a version by Republican Sen. Louisiana courts denied his motions seeking to have the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Miller retroactively applied to his case.
Monday’s decision indicated that life-without-parole sentences for juvenile offenders should be exceedingly rare.
Although more than 2,000 inmates will have an opportunity to appeal their sentence, local jurisdictions have the option of avoiding costly hearings by simply adding the possibility of parole to sentences handed down prior to 2012.
According to the report, almost a quarter of all juvenile life sentences have been concentrated in just five counties: Philadelphia, Los Angeles, Orleans, Cook and St. Louis counties.
Advertisement
The six-member majority, which in addition to Kennedy included Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. and the court’s liberals, said on Monday that it was. The court in 2005 ruled out capital punishment for juveniles and later said they could not be locked away for life for crimes other than murder.
