Grimm is being represented by the American Civil Liberties Union.
Advertisement
In a 2-1 ruling, a three-judge panel of the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a federal judge’s ruling that initially supported Gloucester High School in its case against student Gavin Grimm. Otherwise, they needed to use a private, single-stall bathroom.
Recently, North Carolina and MS also adopted similar laws that opponents say are discriminatory to people who are lesbians, gays, bisexual, and transgender. The case has drawn national attention to the issue of who can use which public bathroom and has put Grimm in the middle of an emotional fight over LGBT rights. “And as more transgender students are coming out and asking to use the restroom or locker room designated for the gender with which they identify, others, including bullies, will know who they are. It is not apparent to us, however, that the truth of these propositions undermines the conclusion we reach regarding the level of deference due to the department’s interpretation of its own regulations”. He says, “I can tell you I didn’t set out to make waves, I set out to use the bathroom”.
Incidentally, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals also covers North Carolina.
A U.S. District Court judge ruled against Grimm in the fall.
McCrory signed HB2 into law after a $42,000 emergency legislative session called to nullify a Charlotte ordinance that would have given transgender residents the option of using public facilities that corresponded with their gender identity.
“This opinion is binding in all the states in the 4th Circuit”, constitutional lawyer Page Pate said. The interpretation of the federal education law directly affects North Carolina. Duke University leaders this week publicly condemned “in the strongest possible terms” the North Carolina law and called for its repeal.
Businesses and politicians have announced boycotts of North Carolina, and legal challenges ensure that the wedge issue will dominate Republican Gov. The school allowed him to use the men’s bathroom for seven weeks and change his name in the school record, decisions that did not receive opposition from other students, The Guardian reported.
That would nullify the portion of North Carolina’s HB2 that addresses public facilities requirements.
The case in Virginia centers on Grimm, now a junior at Gloucester High School. Gavin Grimm, 16, was born female but identifies as a male.
“Today’s monumental decision reinforces the Obama Administration’s position that Title IX protects transgender and gender nonconforming public school students from discrimination”, Nathan Smith, the group’s public policy director, said in a statement sent to The Daily Caller. According to Judge Davis, Grimm “has surely demonstrated a likelihood of success on the merits of his Title IX claim” and the court “would be on sound ground” in granting Grimm’s request for immediate access to the boys’ bathroom while the case is pending.
The court ruled that mandating Grimm to use the unisex restroom was not “unduly burdensome” and “would result in less hardship than requiring other students made uncomfortable by [Grimm’s] presence in the boys’ restroom to themselves use the unisex restrooms”.
“It was just an immediate moment of catharsis, and it was just very, very relieving”, Grimm said.
Advertisement
Parent said that if a situation came up in Portsmouth, he would like to have discussions with the student involved and bring in parts of the community, such as the PTA, before the division acted.
