Schroeder then asks for more briefing on a few due process-related issues and enjoins the enforcement of HB2-exclusively as to the university plaintiffs who brought this case.
Advertisement
US District Court Judge Thomas Schroeder said three plaintiffs challenging the measure had a strong chance of proving that the state’s toilet-access measure violated federal law, and temporarily blocked the university from applying the state law.
Schulman said the law discriminates against the transgender community.
The American Civil Liberties Union, which represents the transgender plaintiffs, and the U.S. Justice Department both argued for a preliminary injunction to block the restroom provision of the law. His final decision on the law won’t come until after trial.
Still, the ruling is not a total victory for opponents of HB2. Defending the law are Republican Gov.
“Today, the tightness that I have felt in my chest every day. has eased”.
“Today’s decision is an important step towards rectifying the harm HB2 has done to North Carolina – specifically the LGBTQ people that call North Carolina home”, said Equality NC Director of Advancement Matt Hirschy.
However, Schroeder writes plaintiffs in the case “have not made a clear showing” they’re likely to succeed in their challenge against the law on the basis it violates the right to equal protection under the U.S. Constitution. But the fight is not over: “We won’t rest until this discriminatory law is defeated”. His description of intermediate scrutiny as it applies to sex discrimination is outdated; in the very case he cites, US v. Virginia, the court elevated the standard, declaring that “p$3 arties who seek to defend gender based government action must demonstrate an “exceedingly persuasive justification” for that action”. In addition, it requires transgender citizens to use public restrooms according to their birth certificate gender.
“The Public Facilities Privacy and Security Act is still in effect”, Bob Stephens, general council for McCrory’s office, said of Friday’s injunction.
“We are thrilled that the court put a temporary stop to some of the grave harm HB 2 imposes on our transgender clients”, Tara Borelli, a senior attorney with Lambda Legal, said in a statement.
Schroeder noted the U.S. Supreme Court stepped in recently to delay implementation of an injunction in the Virginia case that would allow a transgender teen to use the men’s room at his high school. As a district court judge within the 4 Circuit, Schroeder is bound by that determination.
Advertisement
North Carolina university system spokeswoman Joni Worthington said in a statement on Friday that public universities had been “caught in the middle of a conflict that we did not create between state law and federal guidance” and welcomed court resolution of the issues.
