The Irish government agreed Friday to appeal a record $14.5 billion European ruling against Apple’s tax practices in the country, as tensions mount over whether the technology giant paid a sufficient amount on its global operations. But the case is anything but closed, as both Apple and Ireland have chose to appeal the ruling. “It is about State aid rules being implemented fairly so we have a level playing pitch for companies”. They were proud that the tax incentives brought these key U.S. tech companies to their country. Apple was told to repay the money to Ireland.
Advertisement
Apple CEO Tim Cook has already described the EC’s ruling as “total political crap”, and that the decision would nearly certainly be reversed on appeal. The commission denied that allegation.
He also rejected claims that Apple had any kind of special deal with the Irish government. “The EU Commission’s overreach in this regard, is unbelievable to us”.
Both Apple and Ireland have slammed the decision.
A spokeswoman for Apple declined to comment.
After meeting to discuss the matter, ministers are now ready to appeal against the ruling. He said Americans could be hurt by the EU’s ruling if Apple is required to make the payment.
Edward Kleinbard, USC’s peerless corporate tax expert, may have said it best during an appearance Monday on CNBC, a day before the EC issued its widely-anticipated ruling: “The easy days of single-digit tax rates are going to be over”.
White House spokesman Josh Earnest said leaders of the G20 developed and emerging economies would tackle the wider issue when they meet in the Chinese city of Hangzhou on September 4-5.
The EU has made taxation a core issue since the LuxLeaks scandal in which it was revealed that Luxembourg gave companies huge tax breaks while Jean-Claude Juncker, now the Commission΄s president, was prime minister. “It would be totally absurd to choose the area of taxation to attack the US”, he said.
The decision to hit the firm with retrospective taxes was met with indignation from Apple and the USA government.
The EU’s competition commissioner said the company did not pay enough in taxes between 2003 and 2014.
Meanwhile, the United States is only encouraging tax gamesmanship by clinging to a unique (and uniquely punitive) approach to taxing multinationals.
Speaking before the summit, White House Press Secretary Josh Earnest said President Barack Obama would seek to address tax avoidance with world leaders in Hangzhou. “Paying taxes is not optional”. This deprived other European countries of taxes on those sales and ensured that the taxes Apple did pay were rock-bottom.
“This is real change, and it is change for the better”, said Vestager today.
Mr. Dijsselbloem is in conflict with the commission over its ruling in October a year ago that the Netherlands, where he is finance minister, offered a sweetheart deal to coffee chain Starbucks Corp. that amounted to an illegal subsidy.
Advertisement
The Independent Alliance, a group of five lawmakers, had called for a review of how tax is collected from Ireland’s large cluster of multinational companies before it considers a challenge.
