While the policy allows officers to not record when privacy could be an issue, it does not identify specific categories and instances when privacy should be paramount and recordings should not be made. Furthermore, city police require officers to turn their cameras off upon the request of a crime victim (including those of sex crimes) and in sensitive locations and circumstances.
Advertisement
Only 12 of the more than 100 law enforcement agencies in the state have contacted the state Office of Policy and Management about receiving reimbursement for body camera costs under the $15 million program, the office told The Associated Press. After being asked to make their policies public, limit recording outside of confrontations, and limit the collection of biometric data, departments basically did whatever they were gonna do in the first place.
The result is inconsistent use of an increasingly common tool meant to give investigators and an often-skeptical public a fuller picture of police actions. There’s going to be a learning curve, ‘ Johnson said of the body cameras.
The biggest part of the problem, Walker said, is a lack of discipline.
The American Civil Liberties Union has studied the issue and said clear policies are vital, along with punishment for failure to comply.
San Diego police have been criticized for failing to record a number of high-profile shootings. The suspect, Jesse Gomez, shot Wade Irwin as he got out of the patrol vehicle and then fired through the open door and fatally wounded Irwin’s partner, Jonathan De Guzman, according to police.
Eddie Johnson said on Saturday that it was against departmental policy to fire at or into a moving auto when the vehicle was the only potential use of force by a suspect, and police were taking a hard look at training and tactics following the shooting.
It’s unclear if Irwin activated that feature.
The objective of the report, titled “Police Body Worn Cameras: A Police Scorecard”, was to determine if police interactions were transparent and if use of the devices helped to protect civil rights, especially communities with large minority populations.
The Alameda County Sheriff’s Department changed its body-camera policy following a highly publicized incident last November where two deputies were caught on surveillance video using their batons to beat a auto theft suspect in the middle of a street in San Francisco’s Mission District. He did not know when officers in the rest of the city’s 22 districts would be issued body cameras.
Three officers were placed on leave, including two who are charged with assault under color of authority. “We hope that our scorecard will encourage reform and help departments develop body camera policies that promote accountability and protect the rights of those being recorded”, he added. Ray Kelly, an agency spokesman.
State police and public university law enforcement agencies are now required to use body cameras.
MPD Chief James Fry said his department would likely need to hire someone to index the videos and make needed redactions if it began using the devices.
It’s important to understand that the assessment by the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights does not address Seattle’s use of body cameras.
“I believe by the end of three years these things will be built into a badge”, said Steve Soboroff, vice president of the civilian oversight board of the Los Angeles Police Department.
Advocates for the cameras say they benefit the public and police, discouraging groundless claims of police misconduct while motivating officers to treat the public with civility.
The department is going to look at changing training for officers and will take into account best practices from around the country, Bureau of Professional Standards chief Anne Kirkpatrick said Saturday.
Advertisement
There will be some limited exceptions where police don’t have to have cameras on, Hall said, such as when an officer is directing traffic for an extended period and there would be no evidentiary value, when talking to a confidential informant, or at times in a private residence when a person would have an expectation of privacy. “And they’re here to stay”. But they are a great tool and they are the future.
