Until a final decision is reached in the case, the schools – which have said they are caught between conflicting state and federal mandates – can not enforce the language requiring the bathrooms, showers and other facilities people use must match the gender on their birth certificates, District Judge Thomas Schroeder wrote in an 83-page order issued Friday afternoon. UNC had previously said that it would not enforce the law. The Obama administration and a growing number of state and federal courts – crucially including the Fourth Circuit, which holds jurisdiction over North Carolina – have determined that Title IX’s prohibition on sex discrimination also extends to discrimination based on gender identity.
Advertisement
His decision represents a win for the ACLU and Justice Department, which had sued to block the law. His final decision on the law won’t come until after that trial.
Several cases seeking to challenge or defend the law were assigned to Schroeder, while another case is pending in a separate federal court. “This ruling is an important first step to make sure that thousands of LGBT people who call North Carolina home – particularly transgender people – get the privacy, respect, and protections afforded others in the state”.
Apart from the Title IX issue, Schroeder voiced skepticism that the group can win claims anchored on constitutional rights.
Unless it “openly defies the law”, UNC because of the bill would have to treat transgender people as trespassers if they use a restroom that doesn’t match the gender on their birth certificate, he said. “The preliminary injunction will provide much-needed relief to the courageous plaintiffs, and we are confident that this is just the beginning in an unfortunately long journey towards a full repeal of the worst anti-LGBTQ law in the nation”.
UNC President Margaret Spellings has said the UNC system does not plan to enforce HB2, noting that the law contains no enforcement measures. The injunction affects three plaintiffs, including an employee at the Chapel Hill campus, a student at UNC’s Greensboro campus, and a high school student at the state School of Arts, which is run by the university system.
“Today, the tightness that I have felt in my chest every day since HB2 passed has eased”, he added.
A federal court today granted a request to stop the University of North Carolina from enforcing H.B.
“Today is a great day for me and hopefully this is the start to chipping away at the injustice of H.B”.
But members of the LGBT community and advocates roundly criticized McCrory after the bill was passed, saying the law unfairly discriminates against transgender people. In a statement responding to Judge Schroeder’s injunction, North Carolina Senate leader Phil Berger and House Speaker Tim Moore defended HB2 as “commonsense protections to keep grown men out of bathrooms and showers with women and young girls”.
“I got really anxious when it passed because I have a lot of friends, at school specifically but also at places around the country, that are put in danger daily for living their lives as transgender individuals”, she said.
Bathroom access has become a flashpoint in the battle over transgender rights in the United States.
Advertisement
Mara Keisling, executive director for the National Center for Transgender Equality, said the decision is “welcome relief” for transgender students and their families.
