He also cited examples when over a six-month period, people on a low-carb diet lose more weight than those in low-fat diet, but this is all he has to say, “We would suggest that that’s probably because they end up eating [fewer] calories in total”.
Advertisement
A study by the National Institute of Health suggests than consuming low-fat diet is more beneficial that consuming low-carbohydrates diet.
Hall mentioned that some people might find it easier to cut calories by limiting fat, others might prefer cutting their carbs intake.
People seem to have strong views when it comes to which type of diet works best for losing a few pounds.
Ten men and nine women were hospitalized twice for two-week stays, which included five days to establish a baseline diet before starting the experiment restricting calories through fat or carbohydrate reduction.
Carb restriction lowered production of the fat-regulating hormone insulin and increased fat burning as expected, whereas fat restriction had no observed changes in insulin production or fat burning. That’s why low-carb diet’s effectiveness may be overstated, researchers believe.
Diet debate Not all calories are equal when it comes to dieting, according to a new study that shows carb restriction is not the silver bullet to weight loss.
“Our files and our pattern mean that the human body doesn’t treatment which typically fat calories were really minimize”, Kevin Hall, a scientist for the National Institutes of Health, said electronically.
Use these social-bookmarking links to share Low-fat diet trims body fat better than low-carb diet.
The analysis have been very intricately detailed with inspection of every speck of food consumed, every minute of exercise and breath taken in of people on controlled diets.
They said: ‘Consumers can stop beating themselves up for wanting to incorporate a moderate amount of carbs into daily life’.
“This study is also a game changer because the science of nutrition in recent years has shown that people lose more weight (faster) on a carbohydrate-restricted diet”. However, over prolonged periods the model predicted that the body acts to minimize body fat differences between diets that are equal in calories but varying widely in their ratio of carbohydrate to fat.
“Do you have to eat low-carb to lose weight, because if you eat carbs, that prevents fat release from fat cells?”
Cumulative fat loss was at least 110 grams greater with the reduced fat diet than with the reduced carbohydrate diet, although “substantially larger” differences were observed.
He noticed that despite claims about carbohydrate versus fat restriction for weight loss, nobody had ever measured what would happen if carbs were selectively cut from the diet while fat remained at a baseline or vice versa.
During the following 6 days, the calorie count was reduced by 30 percent from decreasing the consumption of carbohydrates.
Advertisement
The findings, from a study of 19 obese volunteers, confirmed the predictions of an earlier computer simulation conducted by the same team.
