He has gone to great lengths to distinguish season-long fantasy sports from the short-term DFS contests offered by DraftKings and FanDuel and in doing so, has framed what legal and fantasy experts say will be a fact-specific debate over whether the DFS contests eliminate a sufficient amount of skill to classify them as gambling as opposed to legal season long contests.
Advertisement
Nevada has restricted daily fantasy sports there to those with gambling licenses, while New York’s attorney general is challenging DraftKings and FanDuel there by calling the offerings illegal games of chance. The companies are appealing the injunction. It makes it more hard for the client’s business partners.
– Advertisements that tout how much money players have won must use net figures, not gross figures.
Kelley said Minnesota’s gambling laws break down pretty easily.
DraftKings, in a statement, called the move, “a thoughtful and comprehensive approach”.
The second factor for a preliminary injunction is more complicated and less predictable.
It’s clear that Healey is not committed too far one way or the other.
“Time and time again, NY has stood in the way, whether by over-regulation or outright banning, of activities that are legal and enjoyed in most states across the country”, Ranzenhofer, who represents part of the city of Rochester, said in a statement. FanDuel has been operating in NY for eight years.
That seems unlikely, at least in the short term. DraftKings, in contrast, continues to conduct business in the Empire State. DraftKings knows that Schneiderman’s cease and desist demand won’t become an order unless a court assents.
The definition sets up two alternative tests, whether it is a contest of chance, which depends on whether there is a material degree of skill or whether the event is outside the contestant, or fantasy user’s, control or influence. “Yet this provision of the law is deliberately ignored by both FanDuel and DraftKings”. The attorney general also proposed preventing players from making deposits of more than $1,000 a month unless they verify they have the financial ability to sustain high losses. But clearly, a message needs to be sent that this is not appropriate advertising for college sports. The few narrow exceptions that exist – which do not include sports betting – all come with strong regulation and oversight to ensure fairness and protect New Yorkers from fraud.
“It’s no different to me than a bowling league that players pay $25 for and get prizes at the end”.
The line about having “some concerns” clearly indicates that DraftKings doesn’t see the regulations as flawless, but a degree of pushback was inevitable.
The Chairman of the MA Gaming Commission, Stephen Crosby, stated that there are other avenues of gaming that sould be considered.
The top prosecutor argued that fantasy sports firms were running illegal gambling operations.
DraftKings and FanDuel deny that their games are “contests of chance”, typically the key element in definitions of gambling. – As the legal wrangling over fantasy sports websites heats up, the PGA Tour recently clarified its policy regarding online gambling.
Boies noted that the dispute in NY isn’t about how the daily fantasy sports games are marketed.
Healey, a one-time Harvard University basketball star, said she called for the ban on contests involving college sports because she did not believe that contests should be based on games involving amateur student athletes.
According to minutes of the May 19 FSTA meeting, Robins “acknowledged that golf and NASCAR do not comply with the letter of the UIGEA”. According to the minutes, Robins stated his belief that operators should not need to operate consistently with UIGEA if they can operate lawfully under state law, noting that state laws pertaining to wagering superseded federal ones.
A Schneiderman aide said he declined to comment on Healey’s plan.
Advertisement
Michael McCann is a writer and legal analyst at Sports Illustrated. “Violation of any of these regulations will be actionable under our state consumer protection laws”. This fall he is teaching an undergraduate course at UNH titled “Deflategate”.
