While Brady may feel that his four-game suspension is of “exceptional importance”, it’s unlikely that the Second Circuit Court of Appeals will feel the same way (unless, of course, a lot of them are Pats fans).
Advertisement
Tom Brady’s battle with the National Football League will return to the court, as the Patriots quarterback will appeal his four-game Deflategate suspension – which has already been issued, revoked and reinstated in a high-stakes legal battle between Brady and National Football League commissioner Roger Goodell.
Last September, U.S. District Judge Richard Berman lifted the four-game suspension, saying Brady was treated unfairly by Goodell. They are analyzing whether NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell strayed from labor law principles when punishing Brady, not the hard evidence.
New England were caught with under-inflated footballs during the Patriots’ AFC Championship game victory over the Indianapolis Colts in January 2015.
Brady’s latest appeal asks for all 13 judges of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to hear the case after it was initially heard by a three-judge panel.
The NFLPA said in its filing on Monday that Goodell’s was “biased, agenda-driven and self-approving” in Brady’s appeal.
An official release from the league confirmed Brady’s legal action, as he tries to overturn what now stands as a four-game ban to start the 2016 season.
After the April 25 ruling, Brady had two weeks to file an appeal and ended up getting an extension.
The four-game ban was announced days after Wells’ report was released last May.
First, Olson will argue that Goodell, when acting as the self-appointed arbitrator in Brady’s initial appeal, affirmed Brady’s suspension based on different grounds than those league officials used to suspend him in the first place. Third-year backup Jimmy Garoppolo would be in line to open the season as the Patriots’ starter if Brady is serving his suspension.
“We’re the union and we represent all of our players”, Smith told ESPN.
Advertisement
The matter has implications for all unionized workers who have bargained for appeal rights as protection, the petition said. “Games routinely are played with footballs that fall below the league’s minimum pressure requirement”, the papers said. Their en banc petition accuses Goodell of falsely portraying the investigation into Brady’s conduct as independent.
