Though such a stance is popular with the Republican primary electorate, it would doom a Republican nominee with the all-important Latino vote just as surely as Mitt Romney’s “self-deportation” call did in 2012. “Americans hate it when people don’t fill out the proper paperwork”, said Maggie Jordan in season one of The Newsroom, her voice dripping with sarcasm.
Advertisement
As with every civilized country in the world, we have laws and we have borders. Of course, that would require the pundits taking their eyes off Trump long enough to notice.
“I’m honored that he wants to copy me, and he’s a nice man”, Trump said, adding that he once gave Walker campaign contributions when he ran for governor of Wisconsin. How many billions of dollars would it cost? More than his two main rivals, though, Walker is unlikely to make it that far unless he can capture some of that outsider energy, too-particularly given Jeb holds massive fundraising and organizational advantages among party elites, and Rubio has positioned himself to swoop in if Bush stumbles.
Republican presidential hopeful Scott Walker appeared at the Iowa State Fair last week, where he was confronted by protesters. Republican candidates thus should be at the vanguard of protecting birthright citizenship, rather than rushing to eliminate it.
Walker made the statement after fellow GOP presidential candidate Donald Trump raised the issue in an August 16 white paper focusing on whether the 14th amendment provides for such rights. For years a small fringe of activists has been fighting that fight, clinging to their own arcane, odd readings of the legally enigmatic “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” phrase. And one trait they share is that they both instituted birthright citizenship.
But Trump is wrong.
Conservatives usually believe in American exceptionalism, and in upholding the Constitution.
In 1930, an 18-year-old Mary MacLeod sailed for America from Glasgow on the S.S. Transylvania, according to a copy of the ship’s passenger list on Ancestry.com. Surprisingly, he did not go after those Mexican rapists who fathered American-born children. Immigration could be controlled to a degree using property rights instead of building walls and issuing a national ID card.
Scaramucci is managing companion of funding agency SkyBridge Capital, and stated he met Trump at his Trump Tower workplace as a consultant of the hedge fund business, not as part of Walker’s marketing campaign.
When people discuss our nation’s immigration policies, what becomes clear is that the system is broken, and tangible solutions are needed.
But other countries would be wise to adopt America’s generous policy. Undocumented workers come to the United States to escape economic hardship and political persecution. Exhaustive studies by scholars and government researchers conclusively demonstrate that immigration’s benefits vastly outweigh its costs. American history is marked by periods of opposition to Irish, German, Chinese, Eastern European, Catholic and Jewish immigration.
Carson said last week that “if somebody comes here for the goal of having a baby, so that they have an anchor baby, we should keep that family together and send them back where they come from”. It expresses a distinctively American aspiration to openness and equality.
That animosity and the sense that Trump’s campaign jeopardizes Republican chances in the general elections has prompted a few consultants to call for the “cleansing” of the billionaire’s supporters. While a number of top GOP candidates – including Sen. In 1986 President Reagan granted amnesty to three million unauthorized immigrants. How he talks about his message with those voters, though, will be up to him.
Advertisement
“All of a sudden now he is saying, ‘No, I didn’t say that, I am actually not going to change birthright citizenship, it is a constitutional right, ‘ ” Mr. Aguilar said. That may be good news for Donald Trump, but it’s bad news for the country.
